Discussions

The II Eastern Hemisphere Gaia Tournament

🌏 Gaia Project
ariallito
Replying to a message

GROUPS

for transparency:

We have 5 players from the first season of this tournament. Including the 4 more experienced. Including 3 champions - putting them in one group would be unfair. Therefore, I decided that everyone would be in a separate groups. As familiar with the tournament system - they will be able to help you explain how to start the second round, etc.

Small rule of our tournament - the last player can decide:

Gaianator was the last to join, I don't know him, we never played together, probably. So I am asking him to complete the line-up of all groups. So Gaianator - please, can you divide players into groups below? (if you do not do it - tomorrow I will ask the next person: Mecenas). Please put each player into the groups. How will you do this? It's your decision/lottery. 

List of groups and players below:

Players

Gaianator, Mecenas, effaraitsch, rescod, Molfo, carioca, Snitz, DukeR, El Temblo, sharath, Markus, vizkris

1. EuroAsia-CUP-group-A

  • ?
  • ?
  • ?
  • bardopondo

2. EuroAsia-CUP-group-B

  • ?
  • ?
  • ?
  • lucasrrr

3. EuroAsia-CUP-group-C

  • ?
  • ?
  • ?
  • Babbuc49

4. EuroAsia-CUP-group-D

  • ?
  • ?
  • ?
  • ariallito

What next ? I will send a link to the games (using private messages here, using Discord, and by e-mail). After the first game - one of the players in the group will put a new link to the second game (using game-chat).

Molfo

Hi everybody!

Thanks Ariallito for all the work you're putting into organizing this.

I just wanted to say, to three misterious people I'll be playing the first game with, I won't be able to play much the coming weekend. But don't worry! I'm normally very present on BGS so we'll make up for the lost time, starting from monday.

Also, I'm in for organizing sessions of live play, if the others in my group are willing to do that.

Good luck to everyone!

Molfo

Thanks for that.

One question: you said that we will use auctions with 0 bid in order to maintain the right faction/player order.

But couldn't we get the same result simply deselecting the "random player order" option when creating new tournament games?

In this way, players will play in the order they join the game, so all they need to do is (A) wait for their turn to enter the game and (B) select the correct faction

ariallito

@Gaianator I can't suggest anything, it's your decision, not mine.

@ effa - thank you for interested. And I'm sorry, I don't understand you. We have crew of 16 players and close registration yesterday, before your post. Am I wrong?

Gaianator
Replying to a message·

I would like to propose a small elo balancing swaps - group D has two sub 200 players and group B only 200+

  • Group B Molfo and Group D Recods
  • Group A Markus and Group B Snitz

If there are major objections I would like to make the changes.

Gaianator

1. EuroAfrAsia-CUP-Group-A

El Temblo effaraitsch Snitz bardopondo

2. EuroAfrAsia-CUP-Group-B

sharath Rescod Markus lucasrrr

3. EuroAfrAsia-CUP-Group-C

vizkris DukeR Mecenas Babbuc49

4. EuroAfrAsia-CUP-Group-D

Molfo carioca Gaianator ariallito

ariallito
Replying to a message

Around the weekend, I will send each of you a link to the games.

The first game: no auction. You choose any faction and play. The second (and next) games: auction as a tool for copying the correct factions order - but I will remind about it.

@Gaianator many thanks for the list, and your points table!

::

What is the prize in the tournament apart from prestige? - unknown player asked.

The award is a diploma, a bouquet of flowers, a chocolate box and a rocket trip to anyany planet in the solar system!* Are you ready for this?

*But I warn you guys that the organizer reserves the right to withdraw from the award due to coronavirus restrictions! #stayhome #washyourhands #keepdistance

ariallito
Replying to a message

IMPORTANT informations & request:

player El Temblo was created a discord-channel just for our Tournament, you guys all welcome: https://discord.com/channels/693041156698669057/887406128290492426

Request: Please vote & decide:

  • by putting: A / B / C as comment. You can also write your position on the proposal [1] & [2]

Manual poll only for players enrolled in the EuroAfrAsia Cup (10 A's required for motion to pass):

  • A: Play all four of your round games simultaneously

  • B: Play round games one after the other

  • C: I don't have a particular preference

It's not mine but also yours Tournament. We play together & decide together. If 10 people choose options A or C, we play: 4 games at the same time.

If you don't understand the difference: ask here or check discussion from Discord channel.

Why am I asking you this?

Some players have an idea about changing the system of games. Please check dissciusion https://discord.com/channels/693041156698669057/702081375309660170 and vote here (forum) or there (Discord), we will summary all voices.

EDIT: But... maybe better way is these proposals:

[1] Each single group can play as they wish if all 4 players agree

and:

[2] In the event of great differences in agreement, Gaianator will reorganize all the groups so that 'simultaneous players' can be put together into 1,2 or 3 groups. And the rest players, preferring old system 'one after another' also put together, into 1,2 or 3 groups. Still we have to keep Torunament's rule: each group is 4 players.

or

[3] @Snitz: all groups should play the same way.

Till now (Discord + forum) :

A (simultaneously) :

  1. Babbuc49,
  2. carioca
  3. rescod

C (indifferent, but 'simultaneously' is OK) :

  1. El Temblo
  2. markus
  3. sharath
  4. Mecenas

B (one after another):

  1. ariallito
  2. effaraitsch
  3. bardopondo
  4. Gaianator
  5. DukeR
  6. lucasrrr (but option A is also ok)
  7. Snitz (but option A is also ok)

:: ps. In my opinion: {1} and {2} is OK: players should try new method. But I definitely want to be in a group that plays in old way: one game after another. If there is no such group - no problem, I will play like everyone else.

bardopondo

Option B. Why not option A? - playing 4 games in the same setup simultaniously would be just monotonous. It would be harder to follow your pre planned strategy for your game this way, cause the games would mess up. I've got this tested in late Polish Leauge.

Following the same winning patern in the next round games is not the issue in my opinion, because optimal moves highly depent on other players actions, which would differ highly as the games progress. The optimal initial mine placement and boosters taken from game to game probably would be the same - but these decicions are rather obvious.
It like chess - the possibilities count in bilions. No worry in coping winning moves.

ariallito
Replying to a message

Let the show beginII.jpg

:: Victory points table: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oGZbKS3j3W4-zEEKHsUQYvKGw5u22QyYEPpuofQWW1I

:: Links to all [completed] games and the correct factions order:

Group A seed: EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-A

https://www.boardgamers.space/game/EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-A

  • Player 1 - Geoden
  • Player 2 - Gleens
  • Player 3 - Nevlas
  • Player 4 - Hadsch Hallas

:: Group B seed: EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-B

https://www.boardgamers.space/game/EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-B

  • Player 1 - Bescods
  • Player 2 - Itars
  • Player 3 - Bal T'aks
  • Player 4 - Lantids

:: Group C seed: EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-C

https://www.boardgamers.space/game/EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-C

  • Player 1 - Ambas
  • Player 2 - Bescods
  • Player 3 - Geoden
  • Player 4 - Gleens

:: Group D seed: EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-D

https://www.boardgamers.space/game/EurAfrAsia-CUP-Group-D

  • Player 1 - Ivits
  • Player 2 - Ambas
  • Player 3 - Itars
  • Player 4 - Lantids
ariallito
Replying to a message

Please notice: it will be our together defeat if someone completely loses game/tournament just because of an absurd missclick.

In such a situation - please report the bug in the game chat IMMEDIATELY. The next player is supposed to wait, shouldn't make their own move. We will try to find help.

Of course, this does not apply to a player's wrong decision. The situation must be transparent, without any doubts!

ariallito
Replying to a message

EurAfrAsia2 semi-final.jpg

Our Discord channel: https://discord.com/channels/693041156698669057/887406128290492426

Gaianator's point-table: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1oGZbKS3j3W4-zEEKHsUQYvKGw5u22QyYEPpuofQWW1I

Good luck all!

Group E

  • Player 1 - Firaks
  • Player 2 - Ivits
  • Player 3 - Bal T'aks
  • Player 4 - Nevlas
  1. sharath
  2. ariallito
  3. DukeR
  4. El Temblo

Group F

  • Player 1 - Hadsch Hallas
  • Player 2 - Taklons
  • Player 3 - Itars
  • Player 4 - Xenos
  1. vizkris
  2. Markus
  3. bardopondo
  4. carioca
ariallito
Replying to a message

These 16 group games really deserve a summary. But by not directly participating in 12 of them - I can only risk unfair judgment.

In my group D, the weakest Lantid result and the worst Ambas result were also one of the hardest fights in this group! So it makes no sense to write that X vp is a low result. In the same way - for example: I know nothing about the actual value of the Lantids scores in group B, sometimes one decision (your or not) can change everything...

If anyone wants to add something or sum up these difficult matches - please.

I can and would like only to write: thank you ALL 16 players for your games!

bardopondo
Replying to a message· ariallito

@ariallito I' ve got some observations and interesting for me afterthoughts, but frankly, I think that revealing them would be somenthing that might interfere with the rivalization.

This setup of 4 identical games leads to particular attitude, faction strenght is something that is less significant here, hence they are all played at some point.

I propose to define the exact schemeing key of picking factions for all 4 games. E.g. : Ist match ABCD 2nd BDAC 3 rd CADB 4th DCBA Or something like this....

ariallito
Replying to a message· bardopondo

@bardopondo

Thank you for your opinion. We will do as you suggested. And we don't need 'auction' anymore, because BGS has fixed 'player order' option :)

Explanation the random order of your group F is:

First game:

  1. vizkris
  2. Markus
  3. bardopondo
  4. carioca

So we're going to shift the order 1 to the right:

Second game

  1. carioca
  2. vizkris
  3. Markus
  4. bardopondo

Third game:

  1. bardopondo
  2. carioca
  3. vizkris
  4. Markus

etc.

vizkris is 'Host of the table'. He will manage the correct order.